Call Us Today (850) 574-6199
Carol's Critters

2401 W Pensacola St Tallahassee, FL 32304

Stop by today and see our vast selection of exotic pets!

Pet Stores in Tallahassee, FL

Carol's Critters in Tallahassee, FL is a locally owned and operated pet store selling a wide variety of exotic pets and pet supplies!

Do you need pet food supplies or aquarium supplies but don’t know where to look?  Do you need more information on detailed ingredients of your cat or dog’s food? Your questions can all be answered at Carol’s Critters, one of the best pet stores in Tallahassee, FL. 

They retain an extensive knowledge of cats, dogs, exotic pets and fish to help you better understand what your pet needs the most. 

Carol's Critters is a full pet store that offers various pet food supplies in many high-quality brands and other necessary pet supplies. Whether you have a cat or a pup, fish or exotic pets, they have all the pet supplies that you need. 

Head over and find a new friend from their vast selection of animals. One of their friendly and knowledgeable staff can help you!

Are you looking to bring home a new little furry friend from Carol's pet store?  Dogs are handpicked specifically by Carol herself from local private breeders.  Carol's also carries a variety of reptiles along with the necessary supplies to maintain them. Browse a selection of...

Pet Stores Tallahassee, FL

  • Birds
  • rabbits
  • guinea pigs
  • sugar gliders
  • skunks
  • chinchillas
  • ferrets
  • and much more

A new pet is both a blessing and a responsibility. Whether you've got a new bird, puppy, baby rabbit or newborn kitten, Carol's Critters has the supplies that your little buddy needs! 

Carol’s Critters understands that customers view their pets as family members and believe they deserve the same level of care and comfort. 

Carol’s Critters can help provide that level of comfort and care with their huge selection of pet-related products, aquarium supplies, pet food supplies and services. 

Get your favorite pet products at Carol's Critters today!


Are you concerned about choosing the right foods for your cat or dog? Choosing the most supportive pet food supplies for their health can be a real challenge, but not if you head over to Carol's Critter's. 

From grooming and canine education, to vaccination clinics and photography, Carol's Can help your furry friend stay clean-cut, nutritionally stable, and most of all, happy. Let this friendly staff help with any questions regarding wet and dry foods and which ones boast the right vital vitamins and minerals.


Bird Food Nutrition is one of the most important categories for psittacine health; these exotic pets acquire an exotic taste. Carol's Critters offers a wide variety of seeds and pellets and bird treats. Treats, fruits and veggies are highly recommended in order to train and keep your bird optimally healthy. From parrots to parakeets, help your bird live a longer healthier live and talk to Carol's Critters about their many different bird food and supply options.

Fresh Water Fish Tallahassee, FL

Choose Us For Fresh Water Fish If You Are In Tallahassee, FL

Are you looking for aquarium supplies for your fresh water fish tank, or pond supplies for your water garden?  Carol's Critter's carries the quality fish-keeping products you need.  The large assortment of freshwater and saltwater aquarium supplies include corals, fish, live rock, and much more! Stop by and check out our fresh water fish we have. We have everything you need from food for fresh water fish to tank cleaning supplies and more!

Selecting the right fish food is very important to the health of your aquarium. Carol's Critters carries a wide variety of quality fish foods, including pellet, flake, freeze dried, shrimp, koi and other types of fish food. Whether you've got filter feeders, bottom feeders or just a Betta in a bowl, you'll find that Carol's selection can't be topped!

Carol's Critters is one of the best pet stores in all of Tallahassee, FL, serving the surrounding areas as well. They carry the largest selection of pet supplies, pet food supplies and fresh water fish! Whether you're looking for a small addition to the family or need a few food items and products, they can help.  Head to Carol's Critters for quality service, affordable prices and for the answers to all of your questions!

Serving Cairo, Bainbridge, and Thomasville, GA & Tallahassee, FL & Dothan and Mobile, AL with all the fresh water fish supplies you could need!

Products & Services

Puppies & small animals, reptiles, hand-fed birds, fresh & saltwater fish.

Get Directions

Click to select your destination


Write Review

Carols Critters

2401 W Pensacola St
Tallahassee , FL 32304

First time buying from here and they're wonderful. Very helpful and knowledgeable of every animal! I definitely RECOMMEND!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (0) No (0)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
Jun 03, 2016
By: Gator

Carols Critters

2401 W Pensacola St
Tallahassee , FL 32304

Carol's is fantastic. All the staff is super knowledgeable, and the prices are great. I've purchased snakes, supplies, a kitten, and mice from this store and have never had a complaint. A great, local business that serves the community well!

Pros: Knowledgeable staff, low prices, product and animal variety

Cons: Hours are a little limited, but I don't mind. It's a local business!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (19) No (3)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
Jul 14, 2014
By: Red

Carols Critters

2401 W Pensacola St
Tallahassee , FL 32304

It is great to have a NON-CHAIN pet store, run by people who enjoy pets, rather than a corporation that simply exploits them. When I go to the big chain stores (Walmart, PetSmart), there are always dead fish floating in the tanks. No so a Carols. The fish tanks are nicely decked out, the animals paid attention to. Also, the frozen rats (for feeding reptiles) are HALF the price they are at the chain stores. Thank you Carol!

Pros: They care about their pets and customers MUCH more than the corporate giants.

Cons: Store hours are somewhat limited.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (9) No (6)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
May 18, 2014
By: Papa

Carols Critters

2401 W Pensacola St
Tallahassee , FL 32304

Was introduced to Carols by one of the employees and it has been a God sent. From picking out the best food from my pets to great advice. A + small personal store.

Pros: Prices are great. Nice selection of reptiles. Helpful workers

Cons: Small store. Crowded

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (5) No (2)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
Nov 16, 2013
By: Tommy C.

Carols Critters

2401 W Pensacola St
Tallahassee , FL 32304

its great I got a dog and eel there and they both live and they are both 12.

Pros: low prices

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (3) No (2)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
Nov 16, 2013
By: andrew

Carols Critters

2401 W Pensacola St
Tallahassee , FL 32304

Carol's is the WORST place. I paid good money for three fish-next day two were dead. I brought them back along with a water sample. They said the dead fish left in the water is what caused the fish to die - why then are all my other fish still alive? I am on a fixed income, I spent good money paying more than market for what I thought was quality fish only to find out this place won't stand behind their product. Really sad.

Pros: The young gal that sold me the fish was really nice - knowledgeable too.

Cons: Won't stand behind their product.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (5) No (33)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
Oct 21, 2013
By: Chris

How Can We Help?

Thank you! Your message was sent!
Please fill in all the fields.
An error occurred submitting your info.
Please try again.

Payments Accepted

American Express Discover Card Master Card VISA Debit Card

Areas Served

  • Arran
  • Baum
  • Black Creek
  • Blocker
  • Bloxham
  • Bradfordvile
  • Bridle Path Acres
  • Buckhorn
  • Capitola
  • Centerville
  • Chaires
  • Cody
  • Concord
  • Crawfordville
  • Curtis Mill
  • Fanlew
  • Felkel
  • Four Points
  • Goose Creek Bay
  • Helen
  • Hilliardsvlle
  • Holland
  • Hyde Park
  • Iamonia
  • Ivan
  • Jackson Bluff
  • Lafayette
  • Lake Jackson
  • Lakeside
  • Lawhons Mill
  • Limestone
  • Live Oak Island
  • Lloyd
  • Lutterloh
  • McIntyre
  • Medart
  • Meridian
  • Miccosukee
  • Newport
  • Ochlockonee
  • Panacea
  • Peck
  • Perkins
  • Plum Orchard
  • Sanborn
  • Shadeville
  • Shell Island
  • Skipper
  • Smith Creek
  • Sopchoppy
  • Spring Creek
  • Spring Hill
  • St Marks
  • St Peter
  • Surf
  • Tallahassee
  • Vereen
  • Wadesboro
  • Wakulla
  • Wakulla Gardens
  • Ward
  • Woodville

Established: 1991